Did No-one See it Coming?
One of the constant mantras from this Government is that the current financial crisis was unexpected and unpredicted. According to Gordon Brown, Britain is uniquely well placed compared to other major industrialised countries. This has been somewhat blown out of the water by the recent IMF report which found that Britain’s recession is likely to be worse than any of our major competitors and significantly worse than the EU as a whole. The UK economy is predicted to shrink by 2.8%, compared to an EU average of 2%. Only Ireland is likely to fare significantly worse than us.
So should the Government have seen this coming?
It doesn’t take too long looking on financial websites to find people who were sounding alarm bells about the level of debt as long ago as 2005. This article is particularly prescient about the reckless lending that was being undertaken by some banks.
The truth is that many people were warning about the huge growth in personal debt, the over-inflated housing market, and the risky lending of so many of our major banks. Because he had received such a good economic inheritance, Gordon Brown believed that the economic rules of the past no longer applied and that the good times would continue to roll. Now the bust that countries face is roughly equal to the size of the boom they enjoyed. The UK’s boom was heavily dependent on personal and corporate debt and unsustainable levels of Government spending.
During his Labour Party conference speech in 2000, Gordon Brown said “We will not put hard won economic stability at risk. No return to short-termism. No return to Tory “boom and bust” and he then continued “why did the Tory party give Britain twenty years of stop-go, twenty years of boom and bust? It is Labour that is now the party for stability and growth.” How hollow those words sound now!
I fear that we must now go through a prolonged period of recession to correct the imbalances that were allowed to bloom on “Boom and Bust Brown’s” watch as Chancellor. Whoever wins the next General Election is going to face economic constraints not seen since at least the late 1970’s and possibly since the immediate post-war period.
Britain is broke and the truth of this fact is only beginning to dawn on the British public. When the penny finally drops, Labour are likely to suffer electoral meltdown on a scale that will make 1997’s Conservative rout look mild.





I saw it coming years ago. I worked as a banker in what is euphemistically called “structured finance”, although not in the mortgage / securitisation / CDS. It was clear that rating agencies were putting a degree of assurance on securities that was not justified by the credit, and that the banks were rushing to create new securitisation structures without thinking of the consequences.
AAA ratings are assumed to be rare commodities, which was one of the reasons why AAA rated paper was given a favourable treatment under Basel II – not only was it high quality paper but the comparative scarcity made the systemic risk quite small. Investment bankls racked up the volume of highly rated paper to the extent that the credit standing of some of the AAA guarantors became questionable, although the rating agencies seem to have been reluctant to downgrade.
Credit margins for corporate lending started to increase over two years ago and the market for new debt effectively dried up in late 1997 when the rates became too high to be attractive to high quality borrowers. After all the losses the banks actually had too little capital to lend, but that was a different story.
I can see it on the night:
Kirkaldy and Cowdenbeath: CON GAIN
We’re you still up for Gordon?
The UK’s in a mess the sooner Gordon is gone the sooner we can clean up his mess and get Britain back on a firm footing.
Another excellent post Richard, keep up the good work!
Alex – thanks for the insightful comment. I think quite a few people were warning but wishful thinking that everything was now different was prevalent.
Cheers Will. Keep reading and posting!
Excellent analysis – I remember back in 2005 a relative of mine, who is a financial risk analyst, telling me that this would happen, and telling me when it would happen, and telling me why it would happen. He was absolutely right on all 3 points.
I think there is a slight danger of us getting a little too complacent. The election is still 16 months away, and although I can’t see Labour gaining support, it would be heartbreaking to ride a wave of complacency into the election and come out with a tiny majority or none at all.
Still, I am quietly confident that we will pull off a big victory. I will keep an eye on this blog, and add a link on my own blog – http://ukpoliticsnews.blogspot.com – which is a new blog, so everyone please patronise it, and leave comments!
Neil.
Thanks Neil – I have added a link for you on my links list!
I remember going canvassing in 2005 with a chap called Richard Willis and discussing at length the long term effects of the UK’s high personal debt.
How right you were…
RFK – ah happy days